River Organics's unscented lip stain gives you soft, buildable color with the feel of a hydrating balm. The Pomegranate shade leaves a bright, natural red tint you can layer for more depth. Made with organic shea butter plus plum and jojoba oils, it keeps lips moisturized and smooth while the color lasts.

Why we chose it: Made with biodegradable and recyclable materials. The color looks effortless, the texture feels nourishing (not drying like most stains), and the ingredients stay true to what we want on our shelves: gentle, and made to actually care for your lips.